Hello!

It looks like you’re new here. To join in the discussion, click the register link below to get started.

Badges

2500 CommentsFirst Anniversary1000 Comments500 CommentsPhotogenicFirst Answer100 CommentsName Dropper10 CommentsFirst Comment
Welcome to the brand new Codemasters Forums! Be sure to check the FAQ and Forum Rules before you get started.

JZStudios Team Principal

About

Username
JZStudios
Joined
Visits
1,379
Last Active
Roles
Member
Points
911
Badges
10
  • Re: D4 Vs. DR graphics

    After playing lots of D4 in various combinations  (stages / weather / time of day / car),  I come to the conclusion that it looks darn good, while being a bit skeptical at first. D4 has very different visual aesthetics than DR (which looks good in its own way) in the lighting and color grading department. DR looks more grim and serious (which is valid aesthetics choice) while D4 looks more vibrant in various weather/time of day conditions. On a rainy stage, D4 is far better looking.
    See, here you're comparing "Aesthetics" as opposed to "Graphics." In 3d, aesthetics is more like the theme or feeling, graphics is the actual visible fidelity, and that includes everything I've talked about here (Minus the Ford.)
    Aesthetics includes color grading, tone, art style, most post processing effects, etc...
    Graphics includes models, textures, lighting, shaders, etc...
    So with both games they're shooting for realism, and I yet again side with D4. DR has some cool vistas, especially in Greece. There's nothing quite like racing flatout on the edge of a cliff drop off on one side, and a cliff face on the other, especially with triple screens as you can see everything.
    However DR has some ugly desaturated colors and most tracks have a brownish color grading on them that looks pretty bad. Take both Greece and Wales for example, why do the greens not look green?

    So, I really like Greece because it's very similar to where I live, and I can't help but think that this ENTIRE mountainside must be seriously dying. I can't think of any other reason those plants would be so grey. It's like it's the worst drought Greece has ever seen. I literally live in the desert where we don't get rain for months and there's way more actual green everywhere. And it's incredibly brown here. Greece does not look realistic. Plants are green with chlorophyll, but in DR it's like they're all dead. Oh, and in DR nothing really looks the same... I know that certain bushes/trees have different shades of green, but the way it is in DR is pretty nuts. Wales in particular has really, really dark trees but super bright grass. It's just weird.
    D4 has natural colors, and if it is PBR, then well... that pretty much settles it. PBR has the advantage of looking 100% correct in every lighting condition. The shaders in DR require all sorts of shader tweaks and lighting hacks to look okay for select environments, probably also why D4 has many more time of day selection options. For some reason people said Australia specifically looks like a cartoon? I really don't understand that.
    httpwwwthereallifeprojectcomwp-contentuploads201302kokkino_lithari_gamila_1jpgw240
    Look at that green in that Greek mountain. Look at that super green bush that's clearly much greener than it is in DR.
    Brown is the mortal enemy of aesthetics and yet people defend it like crazy.



  • Re: D4 Vs. DR graphics

    Well, if this is going to turn into pretty screenshots, here's a few of my favorites from my comparison album.














  • Re: D4 Vs. DR graphics

    So... I could do more comparisons, but because I'm lazy I think I'll just do Hell because there's a massive improvement there if Wales wasn't enough.
    Apparently they decided to change the camera positions/angle/zoom in DR and D4 so getting the same kind of wide shot is sort of impossible.






  • Re: DiRTy Gossip Thread

    Who are you? 
    I'm a forum member stating their point of view on how some people are behaving here.  Ganging up on an individual for having a differing opinion is not very welcoming in my opinion.

    Sorry if that offends your delicate nature.
    I like my delicate nature.
    It feels like butterflies caressing my naked body.
  • Re: Bear's Happy Place

    Here's something interesting.